This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This costs you nothing extra. See our affiliate disclosure for details.
In the Amazon Basics vs MidWest dog crate comparison, the two are closer than most people expect. Both are folding wire crates with a divider panel, a removable plastic tray and single-door or double-door options. The MidWest iCrate wins on size range and matching accessories, while the Amazon Basics crate often costs a little less. For a strong or pushy dog, MidWest’s heavier LifeStages is the better choice than either budget model.
Below we break down the differences that matter, then match each crate to the owners it suits best. This comparison is based on manufacturer details and retailer listings rather than our own hands-on testing.
Amazon Basics vs MidWest at a Glance
| Amazon Basics Wire Crate | MidWest iCrate | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Folding metal wire crate | Folding metal wire crate |
| Doors | Single or double door | Single or double door |
| Divider panel | Included | Included |
| Tray | Removable plastic tray | Leak-proof plastic pan |
| Handle | Top carry handle | Carry handle |
| Sizes | About 22 to 48 inch | 18 to 48 inch |
| Matching accessories | Limited | Covers, beds and replacement parts from MidWest |
| Price level | Budget, often slightly lower | Budget |
What the Two Crates Have in Common
If you put these crates side by side, the overlap is large. Both are designed for everyday home use and crate training:
- Fold-flat design: both collapse without tools for storage or travel.
- Divider panel: both let you section off part of the crate so a puppy has just enough room as it grows.
- Removable tray: both slide out for cleaning after accidents.
- Door choices: both come in single-door and double-door versions, handy for fitting the crate into a corner.
- Open wire sides: good airflow and visibility, which many dogs like. Add a cover if your dog prefers a den feel.
Where They Differ
Size range
The MidWest iCrate starts at 18 inches, which suits very small toy breeds and young puppies of small breeds, and runs up to 48 inches for large dogs. Amazon Basics wire crates start around 22 inches (about 22 x 13 x 16 inches) and also go up to large-breed sizes. If you need the smallest possible crate, MidWest has the edge. For a mid-sized dog, such as one that needs a 36-inch crate (about 36 x 23 x 25 inches for the Amazon Basics), both brands have you covered.
Accessories and replacement parts
MidWest sells a full range of add-ons sized to its crates, including covers, crate beds and replacement pans. That makes it easier to replace a cracked tray or add a fitted cover later. With the Amazon Basics crate, you can still use universal crate pads and covers, but you will need to check measurements carefully. Our crate covers guide and crate pads guide list options that fit standard wire crate sizes.
Price
Both sit at the budget end of wire crates. Prices change often and vary by size, so check the current listings for the size you need. Since the gap is usually small, it makes sense to choose based on size and accessories first, then price.
Strength
Neither budget crate is built for a dog that pushes, chews or works the door. If that sounds like your dog, MidWest’s LifeStages uses heavier wire and is the sturdier upgrade. Our iCrate vs LifeStages comparison explains the difference, and truly determined dogs may need one of our escape-proof crates.
Which Crate Should You Choose?
Use this quick guide to match the crate to your situation:
Not sure what size to get? Measure your dog from nose to base of tail and from floor to the top of the head, then add a few inches. Our dog crate size chart walks you through it.
The Crates
1. MidWest iCrate (36-Inch Double Door) — Best Overall Budget Crate
The iCrate is a widely sold folding wire crate with a divider panel and leak-proof plastic pan. It comes in more sizes than most budget crates, and MidWest sells fitted covers, beds and replacement parts, which makes it easy to build out over time.
- Sizes from 18 to 48 inches
- Divider and plastic pan included
- Fitted accessories available
- Single or double door
Worth knowing: The lighter wire is fine for most puppies and calm dogs but not for strong escape artists.
2. MidWest LifeStages (36-Inch Double Door) — Best Sturdy Upgrade
LifeStages keeps the same practical layout as the iCrate, with a divider and tray, but uses heavier wire for more rigid panels. It is a good pick for bigger, pushier dogs or a crate that gets heavy daily use.
- Heavier, stronger wire
- More rigid panels
- Divider and tray included
- Folds flat
Worth knowing: Heavier to carry and usually costs more than the iCrate.
3. Amazon Basics Foldable Metal Wire Dog Crate — Best Low-Cost Pick
The Amazon Basics crate covers the essentials at a low price: a folding wire frame, a divider panel, a removable plastic tray and a top carry handle, in single-door or double-door styles. It is a sensible choice for a calm dog or a second crate for a car or a relative’s house.
- A budget-friendly option
- Divider panel and tray included
- Single or double door
- Folds flat with a carry handle
Worth knowing: Fewer fitted accessories and replacement parts than MidWest, and no 18-inch size.
Our Verdict
For most buyers weighing the Amazon Basics vs MidWest dog crate, the MidWest iCrate is the slightly better pick thanks to its wider size range and fitted accessories. If you just want a basic crate for a calm dog at a budget-friendly price, the Amazon Basics crate does the job. If your dog is strong or tests the door, skip both and get the MidWest LifeStages. Then follow our crate training schedule to help your dog settle in.
Related Guides
- MidWest iCrate vs LifeStages: Which Dog Crate Should You Buy?
- 5 Best Dog Crates in 2026: Wire, Plastic, Soft-Sided, and Modular Picks Compared
- Dog Crate Sizes: Size Chart by Breed & Weight (Plus How to Measure)
- 4 Best Dog Crates for Puppies (That Grow With Them)
- 5 Best Dog Crates for Large Dogs (70 to 110+ lbs)
- Wire vs Plastic Dog Crate: Which Is Better for Your Dog?
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Amazon Basics dog crate as good as MidWest?
For everyday use with a calm dog, the two are very similar. Both fold flat and include a divider and tray. MidWest offers more sizes and fitted accessories, which gives it a small edge.
Do Amazon Basics crates come with a divider?
Yes, Amazon Basics folding wire crates include a divider panel, so you can adjust the space as a puppy grows.
Are MidWest crates worth the extra money?
The price gap is usually small. MidWest is worth it if you need an 18-inch crate, want fitted covers or replacement pans, or plan to upgrade to the sturdier LifeStages.
Will a MidWest crate cover fit an Amazon Basics crate?
It may, if the dimensions match, but sizes can differ slightly between brands. Measure the length, width and height of your crate and compare them with the cover listing before you buy.
Which budget crate is best for a strong dog?
Neither the Amazon Basics crate nor the iCrate is designed for strong escape artists. The MidWest LifeStages is sturdier, and heavy-duty crates are best for dogs that bend or break wire.
Specifications and prices can change. Check the current listing before you buy.